cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
mercerkg
Pico de Orizaba
Status: Gathering Kudos

There are, already, a bunch of posts asking for a category for the contributor's niche sport (I've made two including a sport I don't do, but my family do). Motivation appears to be to give a sport an equal status but, sometimes, more importantly and altruistically, to avoid polluting another category (such as tagging a horseride as MTB).

I think an "other" category would be a good place to "park" activities that users don't want to delete but that don't fit into an existing category?

3 Comments
eric
Elbrus

I've always considered "Workout" to be the Other category, and I would assume a lot of other users do too.

However, there are some potential pitfalls of a catch-all Other category, including Workout.

Perhaps the biggest downside that I've found is the specific type of data displayed.

For example, runners like to see minutes/mile or minutes/km, whereas cyclists like to see MPH/KPH. The preference for water sports varies depending on the sport, and likewise for winter sports. 

When you select Workout, you don't get any speed/velocity data listed in your activity.  

So I would support an "Other" category that also features the ability to choose which type of speed data to include. For example, choices could be:

MPH/KPH

minutes per mile/km

Knots

minutes/100yd or 100m

 

 

 

 

velocipederider
Shkhara

@eric Yeah, indeed there does need to be a way to specify speed type as you state and names matter. "Other" is prefferable to a word like "Workout" that has certain implications in terms of effort. I commute regularly via unicycle and do not consider my commutes workouts, particularly if I am just cruising along. 

Status changed to: Gathering Kudos
Soren
Community Manager Community Manager
Community Manager